| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Kelsey Shannon; inks: Kelsey Shannon | |
| 1 | Shot to the Heart | comic story | 17 | script: Dan Slott; pencils: Ty Templeton; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Phil Felix | Batman [also as "Matches" Malone]; Deadshot; Black Mask; Eel O'Brian; Alfred Pennyworth; Julie Madison; Harvey Bullock; Renee Montoya; Firefly; Sportsmaster; Gorilla Boss; Black Spider; Bronze Tiger; Phantasm (cameo); Ricky Squib (flashback); Thomas Wayne (cameo flashback); Martha Wayne (cameo flash |
| 2 | Liar Liar | comic story | 5 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Zylonol; letters: Phil Felix | Penguin; Harvey Bullock |
| 3 | Playing with Matches | comic story | 17 | script: Dan Slott; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Rob Leigh | Batman [also as "Matches" Malone]; False Face Society [Black Mask; Firefly; Gorilla Boss; Phantasm [Andrea Beaumont]; Sportsmaster; Bronze Tiger]; Eel O'Brian; Dr. Leslie Thompkins; Lucius Fox; Alfred Pennyworth; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Charlotte Reade |
| 4 | Two Minute Warning | comic story | 5 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Rob Leigh | Batman; Robin [Tim Drake]; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Sportsmaster; Black Mask (behind the scenes) |
| 5 | A Bat in the House | comic story | 17 | script: Dan Slott; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Nick Napolitano | Batman [also as "Matches" Malone]; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Commissioner James Gordon; False Face Society [Black Mask; Sportsmaster; Black Spider; Gorilla Boss; Phantasm; Bronze Tiger]; Eel O'Brian; Charlotte Reade; Jenna Reade |
| 6 | The First Time | comic story | 5 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Zylonol; letters: Nick J. Nap | Batman; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Dexter Jackson; Kazee Jackson |
| 7 | Masquerade | comic story | 17 | script: Dan Slott; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Jared Fletcher | Batman [also as "Matches" Malone]; Black Mask; Phantasm; Eel O'Brian; Alfred Pennyworth; Dr. Leslie Thompkins; Charlotte Reade; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Red Hood |
| 8 | Face to Face | comic story | 5 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Zylonol; letters: Jared Fletcher | Batman [also as "Matches" Malone]; Dapper Hoyt; Cricket Zachs |
| 9 | Deathtrap A-Go-Go! | comic story | 17 | script: Gabe Soria; pencils: Dean Haspiel; inks: Dean Haspiel; colors: Zylonol; letters: Nick J. Nap | Batman; Robin [Tim Drake]; Killer Croc (flashback); Penguin (flashback); Joker (flashback); Mad Hatter (flashback); Scarecrow (flashback); Poison Ivy (flashback); Clayface [Matt Hagen] (flashback); Mr. Freeze (flashback); Two-Face (flashback); Riddler (flashback) |
| 10 | The Couch | comic story | 5 | script: Vito Delsante; pencils: Dean Haspiel; inks: Dean Haspiel; colors: Zylonol; letters: Rob Leigh | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth (flashback); Poison Ivy (flashback); Superman (flashback); Nightwing (flashback); Robin [Tim Drake] (flashback); Batgirl [Barbara Gordon] (flashback); Riddler (flashback); Commissioner James Gordon (flashback); Joker (flashback); Harley Quinn (flashback); Two- |