| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock; the Chupacabra |
| 1 | - | text story | 1 | script: Alexander Grecian | |
| 2 | credits | credits, title page | 3 | script: Alex Grecian, Riley Rossmo; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Riley Rossmo, Tyler Jenkins | John "Proof" Prufrock; Autumn Song; Ginger Brown; Elvis Chestnut; the Chupacabra |
| 3 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock; Ginger Brown |
| 4 | If You Believe in Monsters... | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 2 | script: Alexander Grecian | |
| 5 | Skin and Bones: Part One of Goatsucker | comic story | 24 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 6 | Orientation: Part Two of Goatsucker | comic story | 16 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 7 | A Bone to Pick | comic story | 8 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 8 | Dirty Laundry: Part Three of Goatsucker | comic story | 15 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 9 | Tea for Two: Part Four of Goatsucker | comic story | 16 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 10 | Small Pond | comic story | 6 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 11 | Mother's Day: Part Five of Goatsucker | comic story | 24 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Riley Rossmo; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 12 | Foreshadowing! | comic story | 3 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Tyler Jenkins; letters: Alexander Grecian | |
| 13 | - | text story | 1 | script: Alexander Grecian | |
| 14 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock |