| 0 | Countdown to Season Two... 4 | cover | 2 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock; Wayne Russet; Ginger Brown; the Chupacabra; Elvis Chestnut; Mi-Chen-Po; Colonel Dachshund; August McKraken; Julia Pastrana; the minister; Thunderbirds |
| 1 | Credits | credits, title page | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | Aftermath | comic story | 22 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Dave Casey; letters: Blambot | Mokele-Mbembe; Wayne Russet; Colonel Dachshund; Mothman; fairies; Joy; Thunderbirds; Blue Men of the Minch; Jackalopes; Autumn Song; Graham; Dupond; Rolf; Perry; Hope; the Rabbi |
| 3 | A Man For All Seasons... | text article | 1 | script: Alex Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | |
| 4 | Berserker | comic story | 8 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock; Ginger Brown |
| 5 | - | cartoon | 1 | script: Chris Grine; pencils: Chris Grine; inks: Chris Grine; colors: Chris Grine; letters: Chris Grine | John "Proof" Prufrock; Elvis Chestnut |
| 6 | - | cartoon | 1 | script: Tim Seeley; pencils: Tim Seeley; inks: Tim Seeley; colors: Tim Seeley; letters: Tim Seeley | John "Proof" Prufrock; Ginger Brown |
| 7 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Menton J. Matthews; inks: Menton J. Matthews; colors: Menton J. Matthews | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 8 | Mi-Chen-Po pin-up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Marck Labas III; inks: Marck Labas III | Mi-Chen-Po |
| 9 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Andy Kuhn; inks: Andy Kuhn; colors: Andy Kuhn | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 10 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Hector Casanova; inks: Hector Casanova; colors: Hector Casanova | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 11 | Proof and Ginger Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Shane White; inks: Shane White; colors: Shane White | John "Proof" Prufrock; Ginger Brown |
| 12 | Dover Demon Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: John Amor; inks: John Amor; colors: John Amor | The Dover Demon |
| 13 | Proof and Ginger Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jimmie Robinson; inks: Jimmie Robinson; colors: Jimmie Robinson | Ginger Brown; John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 14 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Francesco Francavilla; inks: Francesco Francavilla; colors: Francesco Francavilla | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 15 | Proof and Ginger Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jim Ken Niimura; inks: Jim Ken Niimura; colors: Jim Ken Niimura | Ginger Brown; John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 16 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Kyle Strahm; inks: Kyle Strahm | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 17 | Proof and Ginger Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Kevin Mellon; inks: Kevin Mellon; colors: Kevin Mellon | John "Proof" Prufrock; Ginger Brown |
| 18 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Christian Ward; inks: Christian Ward; colors: Christian Ward | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 19 | Proof Pin-Up | illustration | 1 | pencils: Gibson Quarter; inks: Gibson Quarter | John "Proof" Prufrock; fairies; the Dover Demon |
| 20 | Archie Snow | comic story | 2 | script: Kelly Tindall; pencils: Kelly Tindall; inks: Kelly Tindall; colors: Kelly Tindall; letters: Kelly Tindall | Archie Snow; Ginger Brown; John "Proof" Prufrock; Mokele-Mbembe; Wayne Russet; the Dover Demon; Leander Wight; Elvis Chestnut; Mi-Chen-Po; Colonel Dachshund; the Chupacabra; Marc Ravello; Autumn Song; fairies |