| 0 | Teddy Payne | cover | 1 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Ty Templeton; inks: Ty Templeton; colors: Tom Luth; letters: Ty Templeton | Teddy Payne |
| 1 | Editorial | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 0.6 | script: Kim Thompson | |
| 2 | Letters | letters page | 1.4 | script: Kim Thompson | |
| 3 | Critters Number 23 | credits, title page | 1 | pencils: Ty Templeton; inks: Ty Templeton | |
| 4 | One Night in the Cold | comic story | 2 | script: Stan Sakai; pencils: Stan Sakai; inks: Stan Sakai; letters: Stan Sakai | Miyamoto Usagi |
| 5 | Christmas | comic story | 5 | script: Tom Stazer; pencils: Tom Stazer; inks: Tom Stazer; letters: Tom Stazer | Lionheart |
| 6 | The Final Blow-Out | comic story | 1 | script: Sam Kieth; pencils: Sam Kieth; inks: Sam Kieth; letters: Sam Kieth | |
| 7 | Right to the Blues | comic story | 8 | script: Ty Templeton, Anthony Van Bruggen; pencils: Ty Templeton, Anthony Van Bruggen; inks: Ty Templeton, Anthony Van Bruggen | Teddy Payne |
| 8 | Teddy Payne | insert or dust jacket | 1 | | |
| 9 | The True Story of the Rise and Fall of the Sinister Ducks | text story | 2 | script: Alan Moore; pencils: Doug Erb, Kevin O'Neill; inks: Doug Erb, Kevin O'Neill | |
| 10 | A Christmas Rap | comic story | 4 | script: John Leasure, Tim Fuller; pencils: John Leasure, Tim Fuller; inks: John Leasure, Tim Fuller | |
| 11 | The Fateful Piano | comic story | 10 | script: Freddy Milton, Dwight R. Decker; pencils: Freddy Milton; inks: Freddy Milton | Gnicky; Gnellie; Gnuff |
| 12 | Holiday Cheer... Musical Fear | comic story | 8 | script: J. P. Morgan; pencils: J. P. Morgan; inks: J. P. Morgan; letters: J. P. Morgan | Fission Chicken |
| 13 | Save the Last Dance For Me | comic story | 8 | script: J. Holland; pencils: Ron Wilber; inks: Ron Wilber | |
| 14 | De Woolf Und De Leetle Boy Witt Lung Hair | comic story | 5 | script: Mike Kazaleh; pencils: Mike Kazaleh; inks: Mike Kazaleh; letters: Mike Kazaleh | |
| 15 | The Origin of Mr. Fly | comic story | 4 | script: Mark Armstrong; pencils: Bob Conway; inks: Bob Conway; letters: Bob Conway | Mr. Fly |
| 16 | Those Newspaper Filler Articles | comic story | 3 | script: Marc Schirmeister; pencils: Marc Schirmeister; inks: Marc Schirmeister; letters: Marc Schirmeister | |