| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Scott McDaniel; inks: Andy Owens; colors: Guy Major | |
| 1 | The Story Thus Far... | recap | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | Identity Crisis... Again | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Tom Fowler; inks: Rodney Ramos; colors: Guy Major; letters: Phil Balsman | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Arrow [Connor Hawke]; Mia Dearden [Speedy]; Flash [Wally West]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce]; Zatanna; Brick (cameo flashback); Constantine Drakon (cameo flashback); Duke of Oil (cameo flashback); Riddler [Edward Nigma] (cameo flashback); |
| 3 | His Name Is My Name, Too. | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Tom Fowler; inks: Rodney Ramos; colors: Guy Major; letters: Phil Balsman | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce] (guest); Dr. Light [Kimiyo Hoshi] (guest); Dr. Light [Arthur Light] (villain); Mirror Master [Evan McCulloch] (cameo); Killer Frost [Louise Lincoln] (cameo) |
| 4 | Cold Reflections | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Ron Garney; inks: Bill Reinhold; colors: Guy Major; letters: Jared K. Fletcher | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce] (guest); Dr. Light [Arthur Light] (villain); Killer Frost [Louise Lincoln] (villain); Mirror Master [Evan McCulloch] (villain); Dr. Light [Kimiyo Hoshi] (cameo); Mia Dearden [Speedy] (cameo) |
| 5 | School's Out | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Ron Garney; inks: Bill Reinhold; colors: Guy Major; letters: Pat Brosseau | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Arrow [Connor Hawke] (guest); Mia Dearden [Speedy] (guest); Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce] (guest); Dr. Light [Arthur Light] (villain); Killer Frost [Louise Lincoln] (villain) |
| 6 | House Warming | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Ron Garney, Ron Lim; inks: Bill Reinhold; colors: Guy Major; letters: Pat Brosseau | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Arrow [Connor Hawke] (guest); Mia Dearden [Speedy] (guest); Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce] (guest); Dr. Light [Arthur Light] (villain); Merlyn [Arthur King] (villain) |
| 7 | Persistence Is Futile | comic story | 22 | script: J. Calafiore; pencils: Paul Lee; inks: Dan Davis; colors: Guy Major; letters: Pat Brosseau | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Arrow [Connor Hawke] (guest); Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce] (guest); Dr. Light [Arthur Light] (villain); Merlyn [Arthur King] (villain) |
| 8 | When It All Comes Down to This, It'll All Just Come Down | comic story | 21 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Paul Lee; inks: Dan Davis; colors: Guy Major; letters: Rob Leigh | Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Arrow [Connor Hawke] (guest); Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce] (guest); Dr. Light [Arthur Light] (villain); Merlyn [Arthur King] (villain) |
| 9 | Cover Gallery | cover reprint (on interior page) | 2 | pencils: Cliff Chiang, James Jean; inks: Cliff Chiang, James Jean; colors: Cliff Chiang, James Jean | |