| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Dan Mora; inks: Dan Mora; colors: Dan Mora | Santa Claus; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Zatanna |
| 1 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bernard Chang; inks: Bernard Chang; colors: Marcelo Maiolo | Santa Claus; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Goliath; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira] |
| 2 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Dan Hipp; inks: Dan Hipp; colors: Dan Hipp | Robin [Damian Wayne]; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 3 | The Eternal Crusade | comic story | 22 | script: Jeff Parker; pencils: Lukas Ketner; inks: Lukas Ketner; colors: Marcelo Maiolo; letters: Pat Brosseau | Justice League [Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Zatanna Zatara; Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Mera; Nubia; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Thunderheart [Iris West; Irey]; Green Lantern [Hal Jordan]; Green Lantern [Sojourner "Jo" Mullein]]; John Constantine; Santa Claus [Agios Nikolaus]; S |
| 4 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bernard Chang; inks: Bernard Chang; colors: Marcelo Maiolo | Felix Faust; Baron Winters; The Demon Etrigan; Deadman [Boston Brand]; Santa Claus (reflection); Robin [Damian Wayne] (reflection); Zatanna (reflection) |
| 5 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Stephen Bliss; inks: Stephen Bliss; colors: Stephen Bliss | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Santa Claus |
| 6 | The Holiday Party | comic story | 20 | script: Jeff Parker; pencils: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini; inks: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini; colors: Marcelo Maiolo; letters: Pat Brosseau | Robin [Damian Wayne]; Santa Claus [Agios Nikolaus]; Zatanna Zatara; Justice League [Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Thunderheart [Iris "Irey" West]; Mera; Nubia]; Korgus; Abel; Blue Devil [Daniel Cassidy]; Extraño [Gregorio de la Vega]; Monkey Princ |
| 7 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bernard Chang; inks: Bernard Chang; colors: Marcelo Maiolo | Santa Claus; Mary Marvel; Robotman [Cliff Steele]; Metamorpho |
| 8 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Marguerite Sauvage; inks: Marguerite Sauvage; colors: Marguerite Sauvage | Zatanna; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Santa Claus |
| 9 | We Three Kings | comic story | 20 | script: Jeff Parker; pencils: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini; inks: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini; colors: Marcelo Maiolo; letters: Pat Brosseau | Robin [Damian Wayne]; Santa Claus [Agios Nikolaus]; Zatanna Zatara; Baron Winters; Doctor Mist [Nommo Balewa]; Etrigan [Jason Blood]; Extraño [Gregorio de la Vega]; Felix Faust; Gentleman Ghost [James Craddock]; Justice League [Batman [Bruce Wayne]; The Flash [Wally West]; Green Lantern [John Stewar |
| 10 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bernard Chang; inks: Bernard Chang; colors: Marcelo Maiolo | Ulah; Mary Marvel [Mary Bromfield]; Robotman [Cliff Steele]; Metamorpho [Rex Mason]; Santa Claus; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Zatanna |
| 11 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Riccardo Federici; inks: Riccardo Federici; colors: Riccardo Federici | Santa Claus; Silent Knight [Brian Kent] |
| 12 | Here We Come A-Wassailing | comic story | 20 | script: Jeff Parker; pencils: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini; inks: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini; colors: Marcelo Maiolo; letters: Pat Brosseau | Justice League [Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Nubia; Mera; Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Thunderheart [Iris "Irey" West]; The Flash [Wally West]]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Santa Claus [Agios Nikolaus]; Zatanna Zatara; Mary Marvel [Mary Bromfield]; Metamorpho [Rex Mason]; Robotman |
| 13 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bernard Chang; inks: Bernard Chang; colors: Marcelo Maiolo | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Santa Claus; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Thunderheart [Iris "Irey" West]; Ulah [Mrs. Claus]; Silent Knight [Brian Kent; Carter Hall]; Zatanna; Metamorpho [Rex Mason]; Mera; Baron Winters; Felix Faust; Nubia; Miss Martian; Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Etrigan the Demon; Mary Marvel [ |
| 14 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michele Bandini; inks: Michele Bandini; colors: Marcelo Maiolo | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Mera; Zatanna; Thunderheart [Iris "Irey" West]; Santa Claus |
| 15 | A Most Magical Holiday to You All | comic story | 22 | script: Jeff Parker; pencils: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini, Bernard Chang; inks: Lukas Ketner, Michele Bandini, Bernard Chang; colors: Marcelo Maiolo; letters: Pat Brosseau | Justic League [Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; The Flash [Wally West]; Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira]; Thunderheart [Iris "Irey" West]]; Santa Claus [Agios Nikolaus]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Zatanna Zatara; Etrigan the Demon [Jason Blood]; Mary Ma |
| 16 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 0.25 | pencils: Kevin Wada; inks: Kevin Wada; colors: Kevin Wada | Santa Claus |
| 17 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 0.25 | pencils: Erica Henderson; inks: Erica Henderson; colors: Erica Henderson | Santa Claus |
| 18 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 0.25 | pencils: Sanford Greene; inks: Sanford Greene; colors: Sanford Greene | Santa Claus; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 19 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 0.25 | pencils: Reiko Murakami; inks: Reiko Murakami; colors: Reiko Murakami | Silent Knight [Brian Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 20 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 0.25 | pencils: Marc Aspinall; inks: Marc Aspinall; colors: Marc Aspinall | Santa Claus |
| 21 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 0.25 | pencils: Pete Woods; inks: Pete Woods; colors: Pete Woods | Santa Claus |