| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Guillem March; inks: Guillem March; colors: Tomeu Morey | Clayface [Basil Karlo]; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 1 | Title Page | credits, title page | 1 | pencils: Al Barrionuevo, Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Charles Paris, Bit | Clayface [Cassius]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface [Clay-Face; Matt Hagen]; unnamed philanthropist |
| 2 | Table of Contents | table of contents | 2 | pencils: Darwyn Cooke; inks: Mike Allred | Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Clayface [Todd Russell] |
| 3 | - | credits, title page | 1 | pencils: Cliff Richards; inks: Cliff Richards | Clayface [Basil Karlo] |
| 4 | Detective Comics #40 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bob Kane; inks: Bob Kane, Jerry Robinson | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Clayface [Basil Karlo] |
| 5 | The Murders of Clayface | comic story | 12 | script: Bill Finger; pencils: Bob Kane; inks: Bob Kane, Jerry Robinson; letters: Jerry Robinson | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Julie Madison; Kenneth Todd [as "The Terror"] (movie star); Mr. Bentley (movie director); Ned Norton (former movie actor); Lorna Dane (movie star, death); Fred Walker (Lorna's old sweetheart, death); Clayface [Basil Karlo] (villain, introduction); Roxy Bre |
| 6 | Detective Comics #298 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff; letters: Ira Schnapp | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Clayface [Clay-Face; Matt Hagen] (villain) |
| 7 | The Challenge of Clay-Face | comic story | 12.66 | script: Bill Finger; pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Charles Paris | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Clayface [Clay-Face; Matt Hagen] (intro, villain, origin) |
| 8 | Detective Comics #478 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Marshall Rogers; inks: Terry Austin; colors: Tatjana Wood | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface [Preston Payne] |
| 9 | The Coming of... Clayface III! | comic story | 17 | script: Len Wein; pencils: Marshall Rogers; inks: Dick Giordano; colors: Glynis Wein; letters: Ben Oda | Clayface [Preston Payne] (origin); Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth; James Gordon; Silver St. Cloud (flashback); Henry Matlock; Matt Hagen (does not appear as second Clayface) |
| 10 | Detective Comics #479 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Marshall Rogers; inks: Dick Giordano; colors: Tatjana Wood | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface [Preston Payne] (Clayface III); Hawkman [Katar Hol; Carter Hall] (small image) |
| 11 | If a Man Be Made of Clay... ! | comic story | 17 | script: Len Wein; pencils: Marshall Rogers; inks: Dick Giordano; colors: Glynis Wein; letters: Ben Oda | Clayface [Preston Payne] (Clayface III); Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Silver St. Cloud (a hallucination); James Gordon; Unidentifed Woman [Selina Kyle; Catwoman?]; Sal Menkin |
| 12 | The Outsiders #21 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jim Aparo; inks: Jim Aparo | Outsiders [Katana; Black Lightning; Metamorpho; Halo; Looker; Geo-Force; Batman, Windfall]; Kobra |
| 13 | Strike Force Kobra | comic story | 20 | script: Mike W. Barr; pencils: Jim Aparo; inks: Jim Aparo | Outsiders [Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Geo-Force [Brion Markov]; Black Lightning [Jefferson Pierce]; Katana [Tatsu Yamashiro]; Metamorpho [Rex Mason]; Halo [Gabrielle Doe]; Looker [Lia Briggs]; Windfall [Wendy Jones] joins the Outsiders]; Kobra; Strike Force [Clayface [Sondra Fuller; Lady Clay] (intro); |
| 14 | Secret Origins #44 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Kevin Nowlan; inks: Kevin Nowlan; colors: Kevin Nowlan | Batman; Clayface [Basil Karlo]; Clayface [Matt Hagen]; Clayface [Preston Payne]; Clayface [Sondra Fuller] |
| 15 | The Coming of Clayface | comic story | 14 | script: Mike W. Barr; pencils: Keith Giffen; inks: Al Gordon; colors: Helen Vesik; letters: Agustin Más | Batman; Clayface [Basil Karlo]; Clayface [Sondra Fuller]; Robin; Julie Madison; Morris Bentley; Ned Norton; Kenneth Todd; Lorna Dane; Fred Walker; Roxy Brenner; Kobra (cameo); Looker (cameo) |
| 16 | The Tragic Though Amusing Story of Clayface II | comic story | 13 | script: Dan Raspler; pencils: Bernie Mireault; inks: Denis Rodier; colors: Helen Vesik; letters: Albert De Guzman | Clayface [Matt Hagen]; Batman |
| 17 | His Name Is Clayface III | comic story | 11 | script: Len Wein; pencils: Tom Grummett; inks: Gary Martin; colors: Helen Vesik; letters: Janice Chiang | Clayface [Preston Payne]; Had Hatter (cameo); Two-Face (cameo); Joker (cameo); Jack Ryder; Batman; Henry Matlock; Helena; Clayface [Matt Hagen] (cameo) |
| 18 | Batman #550 Kelley Jones / John Beatty Cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Kelley Jones; inks: John Beatty | Batman; Claything; Cameron Chase |
| 19 | Batman #550 J. H. Williams III / Mick Gray Cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: J. H. Williams III; inks: Mick Gray | Batman; Cameron Chase; Claything |
| 20 | Chasing Clay | comic story | 38 | script: Doug Moench; pencils: Kelley Jones, J. H. Williams III; inks: John Beatty, Mick Gray; colors: Gregory Wright, Android Images; letters: Todd Klein | Batman; Clayface [Cassius]; Clayface [Basil Karlo] (flashback); Clayface [Matt Hagen] (flashback); Clayface [Preston Payne] (flashback); Clayface [Sondra Fuller] (flashback); Cameron Chase (introduction); Claything [Dr. Peter Malley]; Harvey Bullock; Commissioner James Gordon; Oracle [Barbara Gordon |
| 21 | Catwoman #4 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Darwyn Cooke; inks: Darwyn Cooke; colors: Darwyn Cooke | Catwoman |
| 22 | Anodyne Conclusion | comic story | 23 | script: Ed Brubaker; pencils: Darwyn Cooke; inks: Mike Allred; colors: Matt Hollingsworth; letters: Sean Konot | Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Batman; Holly; Dr. Leslie Thompkins |
| 23 | Batman Villains Secret Files and Origins 2005 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: Bit; colors: Guy Major | Batman; Scarecrow; Man-Bat; Hush; Red Hood; Mr. Freeze; Clayface; Black Mask; Penguin; Killer Croc; Talia Head |
| 24 | If a Man Be Clay! | comic story | 12 | script: Steve Purcell; pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Kevin Nowlan; colors: Matt Hollingsworth; letters: John Workman | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; H. Bennington Screemore; VILLAIN: Clayface [Matt Hagen] |
| 25 | Batman: Gotham Knights #68 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Cliff Chiang; inks: Cliff Chiang | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth; Hush [Thomas Elliot] |
| 26 | The Shape of Things to Come Part One | comic story | 22 | script: A. J. Lieberman; pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: Bit; colors: Laurie Kronenberg; letters: Phil Balsman | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth; Sully; Johnny Williams; Tracy Williams (Johnny's wife); Ms. Kitty (death); Tia; Riley Wilkes (corpse); Hush [Thomas Elliot] (villain); Karl (villain) |
| 27 | Batman: Gotham Knights #69 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Claudio Castellini; inks: Claudio Castellini; colors: Alex Sinclair | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface [Johnny Williams] |
| 28 | The Shape of Things to Come Part Two | comic story | 22 | script: A. J. Lieberman; pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: Bit; colors: Laurie Kronenberg; letters: Pat Brosseau | Hush [Thomas Elliot]; Alfred Pennyworth; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Jackson Davies; Nelson Crowe; Clayface [Johnny Williams] |
| 29 | Batman: Gotham Knights #70 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Claudio Castellini; inks: Claudio Castellini; colors: Alex Sinclair | Hush [Thomas Elliot]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth [as Clayface] |
| 30 | The Shape of Things to Come Part Three | comic story | 22 | script: A. J. Lieberman; pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: Bit; colors: Laurie Kronenberg; letters: Rob Leigh | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth; Jackson Davies; Nelson Crowe; Sondra Fuller [Clayface]; Clayface [Johnny Williams]; Hush [Thomas Elliot]; Michael Akins |
| 31 | Batman: Gotham Knights #71 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Claudio Castellini; inks: Claudio Castellini; colors: Alex Sinclair | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface creatures [as Batman] |
| 32 | The Shape of Things to Come Part Four | comic story | 23 | script: A. J. Lieberman; pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: Bit; colors: Laurie Kronenberg; letters: Phil Balsman | Hush [Thomas Elliot]; Clayface [Johnny Williams] (death); Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth; Clayface [Cassius]; Jackson Davies; Nelson Crowe; Michael Akins; Tracy Williams (Johnny's wife); Johnny's daughter; Johnny's son |
| 33 | Batman: The Dark Knight #23.3 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Guillem March; inks: Guillem March; colors: Tomeu Morey | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface [Basil Karlo] |
| 34 | Not Just Another Pretty Face | comic story | 20 | script: John Layman; pencils: Cliff Richards; inks: Cliff Richards; colors: Matt Yackey; letters: Steve Wands | Clayface [Basil Karlo] (villain); Great White Shark [Warren White] (villain); Secret Society (villains); Vortex (villain); White Rabbit [Jaina Hudson] (villain) |
| 35 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 2 | pencils: various; inks: various; letters: typeset | |
| 36 | Mudslide! | illustration | 1 | pencils: Claudio Castellini; inks: Claudio Castellini | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clayface [Johnny Williams] |