| 0 | The Strangest Cases from Batman's Crime-File! | cover | 1 | pencils: Murphy Anderson; inks: Murphy Anderson; letters: Gaspar Saladino | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; The Wrecker |
| 1 | For Belly Laffs or Blazing Action... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | pencils: Henry Scarpelli, Joe Kubert; inks: Henry Scarpelli, Joe Kubert; letters: Ira Schnapp | |
| 2 | For the Most in Thrills... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | pencils: Nick Cardy, Neal Adams; inks: Nick Cardy, Neal Adams; letters: Ira Schnapp | |
| 3 | - | table of contents | 1 | script: E. Nelson Bridwell | |
| 4 | Batman and Robin's Greatest Mystery | comic story | 12 | script: Edmond Hamilton; pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Stan Kaye; letters: Joe Letterese | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Commissioner James Gordon; Alfred Pennyworth; Mr. Melden (owner of Melden Machine Shop); Jay Caird (villain, introduction) |
| 5 | The Hand from Nowhere | comic story | 8.67 | script: Bill Finger; pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Charles Paris; letters: Stan Starkman | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Commissioner James Gordon; Bobby; Lex Luthor (villain) |
| 7 | These 6 People... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | pencils: Neal Adams; inks: Neal Adams; letters: Gaspar Saladino | |
| 8 | The Man Who Couldn't Be Tried Twice! | comic story | 6 | script: Bill Finger; pencils: Bob Kane; inks: Ray Burnley; letters: Ira Schnapp | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Commissioner James Gordon; Willy Keys (circus clown); Wyler (trapeze artist, death); Dr. Forbes (Police lab employee); James Lee (villain, trapeze artist); David Dial (villain, owner of All-Star Circus) |
| 10 | The Body in the Bat-Cave | comic story | 7.67 | script: Bill Finger; pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Charles Paris; letters: Stan Starkman | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Alec Wyre (villain, inventor, death); Jigger Mulane (villain); Dan Dolson (villain); Hank Purdy (villain, gangster) |
| 11 | Death Row's Innocent Resident | comic story | 8 | script: Bill Finger; pencils: Jack Burnley; inks: Charles Paris | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Commissioner James Gordon; Bower (villain) |
| 12 | Fans of the Dynamic Duo... | illustration | 0.67 | script: E. Nelson Bridwell; pencils: Carmine Infantino; inks: Murphy Anderson; letters: Joe Letterese | Batman; Robin |
| 13 | Between the Covers of This Magazine... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.33 | pencils: Joe Kubert; inks: Joe Kubert; letters: Gaspar Saladino | |
| 14 | To Do or Die? | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | pencils: Neal Adams; inks: Neal Adams, Gil Kane; letters: Gaspar Saladino | |
| 15 | The League against Batman! | comic story | 12 | script: David Vern; pencils: Dick Sprang; inks: Charles Paris; letters: Joe Letterese | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Commissioner James Gordon; Rolf Baglund (sculptor); Burke (Policeman); Thomson (Policeman); The Wrecker [Dwight Forrow] (villain, introduction, writer); Doug Forrow (villain, Dwight's brother) |
| 16 | - | letters page | 1 | script: E. Nelson Bridwell | |