| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart | Edward Grey |
| 1 | Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever #1 cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin; colors: Dave Stewart | Edward Grey |
| 2 | Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever #1 cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart | Edward Grey |
| 3 | - | comic story | 22 | script: Mike Mignola, John Arcudi; pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Clem Robins | Edward Grey |
| 4 | Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever #2 cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart | |
| 5 | - | comic story | 22 | script: Mike Mignola, John Arcudi; pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Clem Robins | Edward Grey |
| 6 | Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever #3 cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart | |
| 7 | - | comic story | 22 | script: Mike Mignola, John Arcudi; pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Clem Robins | Edward Grey |
| 8 | Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever #4 cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart | |
| 9 | - | comic story | 22 | script: Mike Mignola, John Arcudi; pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Clem Robins | Edward Grey |
| 10 | Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever #5 cover | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart | |
| 11 | - | comic story | 24 | script: Mike Mignola, John Arcudi; pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Clem Robins | Edward Grey |
| 12 | Afterword | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 1 | script: John Arcudi | |
| 13 | Witchfinder sketchbook | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 9 | script: Scott Allie; pencils: John Severin, Mike Mignola; inks: John Severin, Mike Mignola | |