| 0 | Front Cover | cover | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson, Tina Alessi | Scary Godmother; Boozle |
| 1 | Front Endpapers | illustration | 3 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | |
| 2 | Front Matter | credits, title page | 6 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Bug-A-Boo; Hannah Marie; Boozle |
| 3 | Scary Godmother [Title] | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | |
| 4 | Bug-A-Boo | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Bug-A-Boo |
| 5 | Scary Godmother | comic story | 40 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother (introduction); Hannah Marie (introduction); Betty the dog (introduction); Hannah Marie's mother (introduction); Hannah Marie's father (introduction); Jimmy (introduction); Daryl (introduction); Bert (introduction); Katie (introduction); Skully Pettibone (introduction); Boozle the gh |
| 6 | The Revenge of Jimmy [Title] | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | |
| 7 | Jimmy & Bug-A-Boo | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Jimmy; Bug-A-Boo |
| 8 | The Revenge of Jimmy | comic story | 40 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Jimmy; Jimmy's mother (introduction); Jimmy's father (introduction; cameo); Hannah Marie; Betty the dog; Bug-A-Boo; Boozle the ghost cat; Ruby (see Notes); Count Max (see Notes); Harry the werewolf; Skully Pettibone; Aloysius the amphibian (cameo); Ellie [Hannah Marie's sister] (int |
| 9 | The Mystery Date [Title] | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Boozle |
| 10 | Bug-A-Boo | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Bug-A-Boo |
| 11 | The Mystery Date | comic story | 40 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Hannah Marie; Hannah Marie's mother; Ellie; Katie; Bert; Daryl; Bug-A-Boo; Skully Pettibone; Boozle the ghost cat; Orson; Count Max; Ruby; Harry the werewolf; Irene LeGevaudan; Madame Zazie the spider; Jimmy; Aloysius the amphibian; Professor Toad; other denizens of the Fright Side |
| 12 | The Boo Flu [Title] | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother |
| 13 | Hannah Marie | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Hannah Marie |
| 14 | The Boo Flu | comic story | 40 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Hannah Marie; Skully Pettibone; Bug-A-Boo; Boozle the ghost cat; Harry the werewolf (cameo); Aloysius the amphibian (cameo); Ellie; Jimmy (cameo); Katie (cameo); Bert (cameo); Daryl (cameo); Orson; Count Max; Ruby; Professor Toad (cameo); Betty the dog; other denizens of the Fright |
| 15 | Tea for Orson [Title] | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Orson |
| 16 | Count Max, Orson, & Ruby | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Count Max; Orson; Ruby |
| 17 | Tea for Orson | comic story | 10 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Hannah Marie; Ruby; Irene LeGevaudan; Orson; Harry the werewolf; Skully Pettibone; Resurrection Mary (introduction); Madame Zazie the spider; Boozle the ghost cat; Professor Toad; Count Max; Bug-A-Boo |
| 18 | Bug-A-Boo Peekaboo | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Bug-A-Boo |
| 19 | Scary Godmother Sketchbook | illustration | 20 | script: Jill Thompson; pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson; letters: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother; Bug-A-Boo; Hannah Marie; Boozle the ghost cat; Orson; Jimmy; Katy; Bert; Daryl; Skully Pettibone; Harry the werewolf; Ruby; Count Max |
| 20 | Recommended Dark Horse Reading... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | script: Jill Thompson | |
| 21 | Back Endpapers | illustration | 3 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson | Scary Godmother |
| 22 | Back Cover | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Jill Thompson; inks: Jill Thompson; colors: Jill Thompson | Bug-A-Boo; Hannah Marie; Bert; Daryl; Katie; Jimmy; Skully Pettibone |