| 0 | Front Cover | cover | 1 | pencils: Gary Gianni; inks: Gary Gianni; letters: Kevin Nowlan, Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | Hellboy; Benedict; Suda (figure on mantle); Ernie (figure on mantle); Big Guy (figure on mantle) |
| 1 | Hellboy 14 | credits, title page | 1 | letters: Kevin Nowlan, Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | |
| 2 | A Christmas Underground | comic story | 21 | script: Mike Mignola; pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: James Sinclair; letters: Pat Brosseau, Mike Mignola | Hellboy; unnamed priest; Evelyn Margaret Hatch (introduction; death); Father Christmas (vision); Annie Hatch (introduction); unnamed creature |
| 3 | Ernie's Holiday Ditty | comic story | 1 | script: Steve Purcell; pencils: Steve Purcell; inks: Steve Purcell; colors: Steve Purcell; letters: Lois Buhalis | Ernie; Suda; other citizens of Toybox |
| 4 | A Strange Story | text story | 1 | script: Gary Gianni; pencils: Gary Gianni; inks: Gary Gianni; letters: Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | Gary Gianni (narrator); Charles Dickens (illustration) |
| 5 | Christmas | illustration | 2 | pencils: Geof Darrow; inks: Geof Darrow; colors: Dave Stewart | Santa Claus; Bourbon Thret? |
| 6 | Toybox | comic story | 9 | script: Steve Purcell; pencils: Steve Purcell; inks: Steve Purcell; colors: Steve Purcell; letters: Lois Buhalis | Ernie; Suda; Visitor [Santa Claus] |
| 7 | A Gift for the Wicked | comic story | 12 | script: Gary Gianni; pencils: Gary Gianni; inks: Gary Gianni; letters: Sean Konot | Benedict; Lawrence St. George; Hoke Hodgson (introduction); Baron Grodak (introduction; death); Santa Claus? |
| 8 | Further Reading | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 1 | script: Mike Mignola; pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | Hellboy |
| 9 | Nothing Says Christmas Like... Hellboy | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; letters: Kevin Nowlan, Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | |
| 10 | Coming in March | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; letters: Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | Abe Sapien; Hellboy (inset) |
| 11 | Back Cover | illustration | 1 | pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Mike Mignola; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: Mike Mignola, Cary Grazzini | Hellboy |